I’ve just returned from a late showing of “At Worlds End,” and it is hard to put into words just how excruciating this experience was. Actually, how excruciating it would have been had the movie not been at times hilariously awful. But where to begin? At the beginning.
First we are introduced to one of the film’s seemingly countless new characters, who is supposed to be of great importance to some important Court, yet will be as poorly directed and flat/undeveloped as the rest of the last-minute new characters we will meet on this journey. Begin series of endless attempts at plot development, fueled by countless turns of “You double crossed us while we were double crossing him before he could double cross you for double crossing him in the past? I can’t believe that! You double crosser! I mean, you’re my best friend and I love you.” It’s like the script was a chemically unbalanced 13-year old girl. No, a PREGNANT, chemically unbalanced 13-year old girl. The only thing the story seemed to be able to make up its mind on was making sure that the two best actors in it, Keira Knightley and Orlando Bloom, get as much dialogue and screentime as possible.
Did you feel my sarcasm? Who on earth okayed this script? What was that meeting like?
“Allright, we’ve got loads of serious, dramatic dialogue to be delivered. Now, we could give it over to Geoffrey Rush and Johnny Depp, two of the most extraordinary talents Hollywood has ever seen OR we could hand it off to the ol’ Knightley/Bloom combo.”
“Well, other jackass writer/producer/directer, I’ve gotta go Knightley on this one.”
“Just what I was thinking, my friend. Throw in plenty of Bloom and it can’t fail.”
WHAT? WHAT? WHAT? You manage to sucker Johnny Depp AND Geoffrey Rush into playing fantastic characters inside a god-awful pile of drivel called a script, and you pass up the one chance you have of making a good movie by letting Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley speak? Only Disney could make a movie with Depp and Rush together awful.
And then a monkey gets fired out of a cannon. Yep. Monkey and a cannon. Now, I’m still not sure which was worse, watching the monkey get fired out of a cannon or hearing the baboons in the theatre laugh and applaud for the monkey. It could be a toss up. Either way, I’m left imagining this scenario: Somewhere, a few years back, a writer sits waiting his turn at a pitch meeting. In his hands is an absolutely stunning script for Pirates 3: At Worlds End. It features tremendous dialogue from Johnny Depp and Geoffrey Rush, a linear, sensical plot with only a few huge and unexpected twists, and the perfect ending to the trilogy. He’s holding Pirate gold, as it were, in his hands. But just as he opens his mouth to deliver the magic, the door bursts open, and in rushes Keira Knightley with a low-cut tank top, Orlando Bloom looking like he’s shooting the middle of GQ, and “random dickweed writer guy,” who happens to look like Chris Farley. The trio are extatic:
“We’ve got it,” the Farley dickweed says.
“Knightley, Bloom, monkey in a cannon.”
The room is silent, stunned at the brilliant idea they’ve just heard. An executive responds, “Throw in 50 million worth of CGI to give us 3 seconds of 200-foot cleavage, and we can start shooting this travesty.”
And then the guy who wrote the good version of Pirates 3 buries it in his backyard and dissappears into the Appalachian mountains. This is how I feel having seen the actual version of Pirates 3. Like somewhere out there, somewhere in the Appalachians perhaps, there is a good version of Pirates 3 that doesn’t rely on hokey sight gags, endless CGI, and grrrl power a la Knightley. But I want to gnash my teeth because I know that version will never be made because the baboons are all settling for monkeys, cannons, and Orlando Bloom.
Hollywood needs to be held accountable.